Another area of Brent Council that I have been greatly concerned in has been Libraries, Arts and Heritage. I have already done lots of posts on our Libraries Transformation Project. Anyone who doubts its success can look up my previous posts on the increased visit and loan figures, the improved home library service, the improved outreach services, improved homework clubs, refurbishments at Ealing Road and Kilburn libraries, improved customer satisfaction and so on.
I want to use this post to talk about other parts of the department. I do regret that I was not still the lead during the restructuring of the Museum and Archive service. This will get a new improved home as part of the Willesden Library rebuild. Brent is increasingly unusual in deciding to maintain its musuem service (where other authorities are cutting theirs) and in maintaining and enhancing the archive service.
The part where I feel I had a bigger impact was on the Arts side. In particular, during my time as lead member I was successful in fighting off attempts to cancel the Tricycle Theatre grant, both during the passage of the Arts and Festivals report in 2011 and the attempt alluded to by Martin Francis in 2013. Aside from the good work that the Tricycle does with the grant in helping excluded young people, the Tricycle Theatre is vital to the economic success of Kilburn High Road. I am also glad that I helped the Tricycle's financial planning by shifting their grant from a one year cycle to (eventually) a three year cycle.
Defending arts spending remains an uphill struggle since many people still see the Arts as an "add on" that can be dispensed with at will. I think this is a very short sighted view, which ignores the role of the arts in bringing in tourism, wider economic benefits and just making Brent a nicer place to live. I am happy to say that the national Labour leadership seem to agree with me.
I wish it had been viable to do more in other directions, but inevitably resources were limited. However, I did my best to support the importance of the visual arts. The LTP also has an often neglected role in promoting the arts. Some in the sector are suspicious of this, seeing it as a zero sum game where arts spend takes away from libraries. I think the two can reinforce each other. The most obvious area is in encouraging writers (Writing is one of the Arts, after all). However the events in Brent Dance month, now made easier by seven day opening of Brent libraries and increased suitability of venues, helps dance groups by giving them venues, and can draw people into libraries who might not generally use them. One of my regrets in this area is that we did not find a way to use public buildings as hanging space more comprehensively, although I was pleased we did manage to create Brent's first artist in residence schemes for sculpture and poetry.
On the. Ultralight side, I should also mention our role as an Olympic Borough. To be frank my main concern was in case there was a screw up, which thankfully was not the case. It all went quite smoothly.
Search This Blog
Wednesday, 21 May 2014
Tuesday, 20 May 2014
Public Realm and Planning
Another area of Council achievement that I think deserves more praise than it gets is in the development of public space. Much of the improvement here should come through the Public Realm contract and the changes hopefully embedded in procedures by the Placemaking Guide.
However, there has also been major progress around specific areas. The biggest of these is Wembley, which has really come together with the new Civic Centre. I think the crucial points are that (a) a number of different features _ the Civic Centre, the retail facilities, the Arena, the Stadium and so on _ come together in a way that makes a bigger impact that any of them could do individually (b) the street scene works in a way that knits the different areas together. The importance of that second point is best illustrated by an area such as South Kilburn, where the street scene signally fails to link the disparate elements.
A third point that I don't feel is always picked up on, is the way that areas outside a buidling relate to the inside. Wembley Library benefits from the gallery space and atrium (pictured below) as events and activities bleed from one to another. I hope that Wembley Market Square will soon have a similar function. It is also noticeable how the tables around the atrium and surrounding areas are used by teenagers who I suspect are also using the library facilities.
However, there has also been major progress around specific areas. The biggest of these is Wembley, which has really come together with the new Civic Centre. I think the crucial points are that (a) a number of different features _ the Civic Centre, the retail facilities, the Arena, the Stadium and so on _ come together in a way that makes a bigger impact that any of them could do individually (b) the street scene works in a way that knits the different areas together. The importance of that second point is best illustrated by an area such as South Kilburn, where the street scene signally fails to link the disparate elements.
A third point that I don't feel is always picked up on, is the way that areas outside a buidling relate to the inside. Wembley Library benefits from the gallery space and atrium (pictured below) as events and activities bleed from one to another. I hope that Wembley Market Square will soon have a similar function. It is also noticeable how the tables around the atrium and surrounding areas are used by teenagers who I suspect are also using the library facilities.
These often seem to be overlooked in political debates which are often about how much money to spend, rather than the way in which it is spent.
Monday, 19 May 2014
Willesden Library in Use as a Polling Station
There have been false claims that Willesden Green Library is closed. On polling day, the George Furness part of Willesden Green Library actually will be closed, as it will be in use as a polling station. However, you can still access library facilities at the Lewinson Centre three minutes walk along Willesden High Road or Kilburn Library, or indeed Harlesden Library. You can also take the Tube up to Wembley Library if you so wish.
Sunday, 18 May 2014
Waste and Recycling in Brent
Another area that I thought would be controversial in Brent but turned out not to be was the various changes we made to waste management. This started with the introduction of the blue top bins. A second wave of more incremental change followed in April 2013. We also introduced improvements to the Council's internal processes, amended the old waste contract and negotiated the new Public Realm contract.
Less visibly, West London Waste has gone through a transformation with the award of a new contract to Sita, which will see the waste from West London shift from being sent to landfill at Calvert to being burnt for energy. From the later part of 2016, the proportion of West London waste sent to landfill should fall below 5%.
Less visibly, West London Waste has gone through a transformation with the award of a new contract to Sita, which will see the waste from West London shift from being sent to landfill at Calvert to being burnt for energy. From the later part of 2016, the proportion of West London waste sent to landfill should fall below 5%.
Saturday, 17 May 2014
Climate Change and the Green Charter
As I said yesterday, I am doing a few posts over what has been achieved over the past four years. In terms of climate change, Brent has built one of the greenest buildings in Europe in Brent Civic Centre, further improved environmental performance at other buildings such as Willesden Cultural Centre and Kilburn Library, improved planning guidelines in terms of environmental performance, reduced greenhouse gas emissions from waste management, plans for district heating in Wembley and Kilburn and introduced emissions based parking permits. We have also encouraged the take up of car clubs. Although I found it disappointing in some ways, the Climate Change Steering Group succeeded in having worthwhile events geared at raising awareness of business and of schools. There has not been as much progress as one might hope, but there was a noticeable improvement on the previous quadrennial.
The other key change in Green Charter terms from the previous Lib Dem / Tory administration was the achieving and renewal of the Fairtrade status.
The other key change in Green Charter terms from the previous Lib Dem / Tory administration was the achieving and renewal of the Fairtrade status.
Friday, 16 May 2014
Election Prediction
Some one asked me recently how the elections are going in Brent. I have always been quite wary of predictions, but I shall be surprised if Labour does not come back with a good, possibly increased, majority.
The main Labour opponent in Brent are the Liberal Democrats, and they have been shattered by the shock of going into coalition with the Tories. Especially in Labour leaning areas, their pitch was to be Labour without the difficult bits, so clubbing together with the Tories in the most right wing government this country has seen for decades was an enormous blow to many of their supporters. Locally, I am told their membership is falling, and that they struggled to get a full slate of candidates. Indeed, some of their candidates are not even Brent residents.
The Tories in Brent are somewhat isolated from general trends. There is only a limited UKIP presence here, but the Tory organisation is again threadbare and has been for some time.
The Greens, perhaps wisely, have drawn their horns in compared to previous elections.
The main Labour opponent in Brent are the Liberal Democrats, and they have been shattered by the shock of going into coalition with the Tories. Especially in Labour leaning areas, their pitch was to be Labour without the difficult bits, so clubbing together with the Tories in the most right wing government this country has seen for decades was an enormous blow to many of their supporters. Locally, I am told their membership is falling, and that they struggled to get a full slate of candidates. Indeed, some of their candidates are not even Brent residents.
The Tories in Brent are somewhat isolated from general trends. There is only a limited UKIP presence here, but the Tory organisation is again threadbare and has been for some time.
The Greens, perhaps wisely, have drawn their horns in compared to previous elections.
Sports, Parks and Cemeteries in Brent
As the elections draw close I thought I would reflect on what has been achieved in different parts of the Council that I have been involved in the past four years.
Cemeteries have been quite a quiet area, which surprises me given that potentially one can imagine plenty of scope for controversies. Following the merger of the cemetery department with parks in late 2010, we put together Brent's first comprehensive cemetery strategy for many years. As I have pointed out with the allotments strategy previously, having a coherent worked out strategy helps gives shape and accountability to Council services.
On parks, we managed not just to bundle it with the rest of the Public Realm Contract to create a more seamless service, we also changed the planting regime to bring it in line with expectations of climate change. We also had a large range of investments in Brent parks, including the Borough's first new park for many years at Chalkhill, outdoor gym equipment in several parks, improvements at Tubbs park, improvements at Furness park, Challenge Close in Harlesden improvements, the BMX track near St David's Close, improvements at Tiverton Green, improvements in Gladstone Park following the demolition of Dollis Hill House, the granting of nature reserve status to Mason's field and a longer term strategy for Barham Park. We also saw new measures to regulate dogs and dangerous and wild animals in parks.
With sports, we concluded an award winning cross Borough contract to run Vale Farm. A new sports centre (owned by Westminster) is being built at Moberley. There are possible plans for Bridge Park and Dexion House, although these are far from being settled.
Altogether, that seems to me to be quite a lot of stuff.
Cemeteries have been quite a quiet area, which surprises me given that potentially one can imagine plenty of scope for controversies. Following the merger of the cemetery department with parks in late 2010, we put together Brent's first comprehensive cemetery strategy for many years. As I have pointed out with the allotments strategy previously, having a coherent worked out strategy helps gives shape and accountability to Council services.
On parks, we managed not just to bundle it with the rest of the Public Realm Contract to create a more seamless service, we also changed the planting regime to bring it in line with expectations of climate change. We also had a large range of investments in Brent parks, including the Borough's first new park for many years at Chalkhill, outdoor gym equipment in several parks, improvements at Tubbs park, improvements at Furness park, Challenge Close in Harlesden improvements, the BMX track near St David's Close, improvements at Tiverton Green, improvements in Gladstone Park following the demolition of Dollis Hill House, the granting of nature reserve status to Mason's field and a longer term strategy for Barham Park. We also saw new measures to regulate dogs and dangerous and wild animals in parks.
With sports, we concluded an award winning cross Borough contract to run Vale Farm. A new sports centre (owned by Westminster) is being built at Moberley. There are possible plans for Bridge Park and Dexion House, although these are far from being settled.
Altogether, that seems to me to be quite a lot of stuff.
Thursday, 15 May 2014
Local Government Association Financial Gloom
The Local Government Association has come out with another gloomy report on Council finances. It estimates that 60% of Councils will be under serious pressure in 2015/16. Only 20% think they can cope financially simply through more efficiencies. By now, I am surprised that figure is so high, as years of shrinking budgets have been the lot of most Councils for some time now.
Looking at the suggested options in the report, I am struck that Brent has tried most of them.
Increasing fees and charges: Brent put up most of its fees and charges in 2011, and adopted a default of inflation or above increases. There may be a few minor adjustments that can be made, but there is little likelihood of any significant rise in revenue. Brent does not really have substantial assets to invest and gain further income that way.
Using Reserves: Brent has historically had very low reserves. They were only £7.5 million when the current Labour administration was elected in 2010, and it is only about £12 million now. In 2010, George Osborne's "emergency budget" gave us a projected overspend of more than £7 million, and I would think the possibilities for future overspend are greater. Those authorities that use their reserves can only delay the issue.
Increasing the Tax Base: Scope for raising Council Tax is limited by the referendum criteria. Building new homes increases the tax base, but is limited by lack of land, planning considerations and the vagaries of the market.
Reviewing the use of assets: The Council has had a policy of tightening its property management for some time. The obvious big example is the Civic Centre, which was the centrepiece of a policy to reduce the Council's property portfolio. However, Brent Council does not actually own many buildings, and disposing of them can sometimes run into planning and other problems.
In addition to these, Brent Council has engaged in a number of genuinely transformative projects. Although the libraries have hogged much of the publicity, there have been other financially more significant examples such as the increase in recycling and a lot of the activity around adult social care, helping people to stay independent for longer. There have been a few examples of ceasing to do things altogether, notably in the festivals strategy. There will have to be more such examples over the next four years.
Looking at the suggested options in the report, I am struck that Brent has tried most of them.
Increasing fees and charges: Brent put up most of its fees and charges in 2011, and adopted a default of inflation or above increases. There may be a few minor adjustments that can be made, but there is little likelihood of any significant rise in revenue. Brent does not really have substantial assets to invest and gain further income that way.
Using Reserves: Brent has historically had very low reserves. They were only £7.5 million when the current Labour administration was elected in 2010, and it is only about £12 million now. In 2010, George Osborne's "emergency budget" gave us a projected overspend of more than £7 million, and I would think the possibilities for future overspend are greater. Those authorities that use their reserves can only delay the issue.
Increasing the Tax Base: Scope for raising Council Tax is limited by the referendum criteria. Building new homes increases the tax base, but is limited by lack of land, planning considerations and the vagaries of the market.
Reviewing the use of assets: The Council has had a policy of tightening its property management for some time. The obvious big example is the Civic Centre, which was the centrepiece of a policy to reduce the Council's property portfolio. However, Brent Council does not actually own many buildings, and disposing of them can sometimes run into planning and other problems.
In addition to these, Brent Council has engaged in a number of genuinely transformative projects. Although the libraries have hogged much of the publicity, there have been other financially more significant examples such as the increase in recycling and a lot of the activity around adult social care, helping people to stay independent for longer. There have been a few examples of ceasing to do things altogether, notably in the festivals strategy. There will have to be more such examples over the next four years.
Wednesday, 14 May 2014
Letting Agent Vote
The House of Commons voted on letting agents on the Consumer Rights Bill, following Stella Creasy tabling an amendment on the issue. The idea of the amendment is to help people renting privately who find themselves being ripped off by landlords. Exactly the kind of thing that effects many people in Brent Central. Almost all Tory and Liberal MPs voted against.
Sarah Teather chose to be absent.
Sarah Teather chose to be absent.
Debating the Issues
I had another comment on the libraries issue on this blog, which I am not going to publish as it is abusive about a named councillor. Descending to personal abuse in anonymous posts is not an attractive characteristic.
However, the phenomenon of ad hominum attacks is worth commenting on. I have mentioned before that both councillors and officers get targeted personally by these commentators. One way of seeing this is as a campaign target for people with a weak case. If the facts support your opponent, an obvious way to overcome that is to smear the person rather than the policy.
I think, however, that is just too rational.
The people concerned just seem too enraged. Taking the libraries issue. One might imagine that anyone who thinks libraries are a good thing would welcome the increase in numbers at Brent libraries, not to mention the greater satisfaction levels of Brent library users. If you are a Brent resident, you might take some satisfaction in Brent libraries outperforming those elsewhere.
In fact all these facts just seem to make some people angry, and I can only assume that these sort of debates have become personal contests for them devoid of actual effects. The actual effect on peoples' lives is simply a non-issue for them, because they are just interested in proving themselves right in some sort of self absorbed debating game.
However, the phenomenon of ad hominum attacks is worth commenting on. I have mentioned before that both councillors and officers get targeted personally by these commentators. One way of seeing this is as a campaign target for people with a weak case. If the facts support your opponent, an obvious way to overcome that is to smear the person rather than the policy.
I think, however, that is just too rational.
The people concerned just seem too enraged. Taking the libraries issue. One might imagine that anyone who thinks libraries are a good thing would welcome the increase in numbers at Brent libraries, not to mention the greater satisfaction levels of Brent library users. If you are a Brent resident, you might take some satisfaction in Brent libraries outperforming those elsewhere.
In fact all these facts just seem to make some people angry, and I can only assume that these sort of debates have become personal contests for them devoid of actual effects. The actual effect on peoples' lives is simply a non-issue for them, because they are just interested in proving themselves right in some sort of self absorbed debating game.
Tuesday, 13 May 2014
More on Harlesden Town Centre Parking
In a follow up on my previous post, officers have informed me that there are some technical difficulties around enforcement in Harlesden Town Centre. Enforcement needs precisely worded traffic orders, and these are still being drafted for the new layout. Unfortunately there is a statutory consultation period, so that they will not be ready until September. However, enforcement against double parking or parking on the pavement is ongoing.
Monday, 12 May 2014
Resources and Free Schools
The Liberal Democrats are waking up to the damaging effects of Michael Gove's free school policy. A pity that such concerns did not occur to them before they voted for it. Then the damage might have been prevented, rather than just resulting in an exchange of childish insults.
Possible misdirection of resources is an obvious possibility in any system which depends on groups of people gathering together and bidding for resources. That applies to schools and to other areas. It is a constant complaint among those outside London that well connected lobbyists in the Capital get disproportionate resources. Within an area, such as a Borough, there is an obvious danger that people who are good at publicity will obtain resources at the expense of those in greater need.
The solution lies partly in having correct procedures for allocating resources, and partly in having decision makers with the guts to stick with them. Decision makers who cave in to the pressure of (generally) wealthy lobbyists are betraying not just the people who have resources directly withdrawn, but also the public who want their money spent wisely.
Possible misdirection of resources is an obvious possibility in any system which depends on groups of people gathering together and bidding for resources. That applies to schools and to other areas. It is a constant complaint among those outside London that well connected lobbyists in the Capital get disproportionate resources. Within an area, such as a Borough, there is an obvious danger that people who are good at publicity will obtain resources at the expense of those in greater need.
The solution lies partly in having correct procedures for allocating resources, and partly in having decision makers with the guts to stick with them. Decision makers who cave in to the pressure of (generally) wealthy lobbyists are betraying not just the people who have resources directly withdrawn, but also the public who want their money spent wisely.
Sunday, 11 May 2014
WEEE Recycling at the Tricycle Theatre
From tomorrow, the Tricycle Theatre will be hosting another opportunity to recycle electrical goods. This is in partnership with the West London Waste Authority (WLWA), and runs from 12 to 18 May. It follows a similar initiative in January.
Saturday, 10 May 2014
Willesden Green Library Images
Willesden Green Labour candidate Bernard Collier has posted a number of photographs of the building work at Willesden Library Centre here. It includes an image of the Brondesbury Park side as it is expected to look on completion. The view contrasts with the dead frontage provided by the old building.
Happy World Fairtrade Day
Today is World Fairtrade Day. Brent Fairtrade Network is teaming up with Harrow for a Fairtrade event there.
Friday, 9 May 2014
Barham Park Planning Appeal and Local Democracy
Barham Park has been the subject of a lengthy blog by Philip Grant on Wembley Matters. Without wishing to pick on anyone, I think it worth looking at in detail as it illustrates many of the confusions about local government debates that create unnecessary heat.
Member and Officer Roles
One of the key confusions is between the roles of members and officers. The elected members (councillors) determine the policy of the Council in committee. The reports that committee considers is a set of recommendation by Council officers, based on their professional expertise. Therefore the suggestion that there is a split where the officers are forcing the councillors to make a decision is wrong, and cannot be right. When councillors feel they are being "forced" into a decision that usually means that they cannot think of an argument why the officer recommendation is wrong. To me, that seems more likely councillors failing to engage intellectually.
Essentially, the role of officers is to give information and advice on technocratic questions like cost, legality, feasibility and so on. The councillors are supposed to make value judgements. For instance how much weight should be given to retaining community space compared to bringing it into use for another purpose, for example?
The odd thing about Mr Grant's post is that he explicitly refers to officers being overruled by councillors in an earlier planning decision, but seems to feel that councillors were "forced" to follow advice at a meeting of the Barham Trust where the councillors decided to appeal the planning refusal.
The Barham Park Trust
The five members of the Barham Park Trust could have overruled the officers in exactly the same way as the Planning Committee. They interpreted their role as trustee as appealing the planning refusal, which is entirely in line with the earlier decision to rent out the property to ACAVA. The Council officers are simply implementing the decision that the councillors have made. They would be professionally remiss, and probably sackable, if they did anything else.
Incidentally, I dislike the way that Mr Grant names specific officers and accuses them of particular forms of misconduct. Not only have none of these officers committed any misconduct, by convention they cannot answer back to such accusations. To make personal criticisms of named individuals when they cannot answer back violates the principles of basic fairness.
What is the Agenda Here?
I am now going into speculation about motives, which is risky as I think Mr Grant demonstrates. I don't think his speculations about various peoples' motivations make sense, and in speculating on other peoples' motives I risk the same problem. However, here goes.
This whole row has essentially been whipped up by Cllr Paul Lorber, who seems to me to have two motivations. One is party political. He wants to whip up controversy ahead of the election on 22 May as he thinks that may benefit his party. That is perhaps understandable. The second relates to his position as one of the bidders in the original tendering process. Despite his best efforts to muscle in on the committee's decision, Cllr Lorber's bid was considered on the same basis as everyone else. I was on the Committee and it was obvious to me that Cllr Lorber's bid was markedly inferior to that of ACAVA. I believe that Cllr Lorber's second motivation for seeking to use legal and planning objections to block the new tenant is down to a combination of sour grapes and an attempt to use the planning process to secure a tenancy when a decision was made not to give him one.
Member and Officer Roles
One of the key confusions is between the roles of members and officers. The elected members (councillors) determine the policy of the Council in committee. The reports that committee considers is a set of recommendation by Council officers, based on their professional expertise. Therefore the suggestion that there is a split where the officers are forcing the councillors to make a decision is wrong, and cannot be right. When councillors feel they are being "forced" into a decision that usually means that they cannot think of an argument why the officer recommendation is wrong. To me, that seems more likely councillors failing to engage intellectually.
Essentially, the role of officers is to give information and advice on technocratic questions like cost, legality, feasibility and so on. The councillors are supposed to make value judgements. For instance how much weight should be given to retaining community space compared to bringing it into use for another purpose, for example?
The odd thing about Mr Grant's post is that he explicitly refers to officers being overruled by councillors in an earlier planning decision, but seems to feel that councillors were "forced" to follow advice at a meeting of the Barham Trust where the councillors decided to appeal the planning refusal.
The Barham Park Trust
The five members of the Barham Park Trust could have overruled the officers in exactly the same way as the Planning Committee. They interpreted their role as trustee as appealing the planning refusal, which is entirely in line with the earlier decision to rent out the property to ACAVA. The Council officers are simply implementing the decision that the councillors have made. They would be professionally remiss, and probably sackable, if they did anything else.
Incidentally, I dislike the way that Mr Grant names specific officers and accuses them of particular forms of misconduct. Not only have none of these officers committed any misconduct, by convention they cannot answer back to such accusations. To make personal criticisms of named individuals when they cannot answer back violates the principles of basic fairness.
What is the Agenda Here?
I am now going into speculation about motives, which is risky as I think Mr Grant demonstrates. I don't think his speculations about various peoples' motivations make sense, and in speculating on other peoples' motives I risk the same problem. However, here goes.
This whole row has essentially been whipped up by Cllr Paul Lorber, who seems to me to have two motivations. One is party political. He wants to whip up controversy ahead of the election on 22 May as he thinks that may benefit his party. That is perhaps understandable. The second relates to his position as one of the bidders in the original tendering process. Despite his best efforts to muscle in on the committee's decision, Cllr Lorber's bid was considered on the same basis as everyone else. I was on the Committee and it was obvious to me that Cllr Lorber's bid was markedly inferior to that of ACAVA. I believe that Cllr Lorber's second motivation for seeking to use legal and planning objections to block the new tenant is down to a combination of sour grapes and an attempt to use the planning process to secure a tenancy when a decision was made not to give him one.
Thursday, 8 May 2014
Lessons from New York?
Help to Buy has been condemned by both Tory and Labour former Chancellors. Let us hope George takes notice. It is a deeply stupid policy.
Meanwhile, the Mayor of New York is putting forward some interesting plans for affordable housing over there. New York is about as close a comparison to London as you can get, so let us hope that we can learn from whatever the Americans propose. There is a lot in it, but as I have pointed out before, these things are not just about saying what you want and getting it.
His proposal for trading extra height for a greater proportion of affordable housing is an interesting one, which might work over here. It could work if the economics stack up, but I can see it being controversial. More tall buildings will not go down well with many people. Family housing in blocks with little or no amenity space may not be suitable, and lack of family housing is one of the big problems in areas like Brent. The big problem is that developers might simply choose not to make an application in the first place if they don't think they will get sufficient profit.
Meanwhile, the Mayor of New York is putting forward some interesting plans for affordable housing over there. New York is about as close a comparison to London as you can get, so let us hope that we can learn from whatever the Americans propose. There is a lot in it, but as I have pointed out before, these things are not just about saying what you want and getting it.
His proposal for trading extra height for a greater proportion of affordable housing is an interesting one, which might work over here. It could work if the economics stack up, but I can see it being controversial. More tall buildings will not go down well with many people. Family housing in blocks with little or no amenity space may not be suitable, and lack of family housing is one of the big problems in areas like Brent. The big problem is that developers might simply choose not to make an application in the first place if they don't think they will get sufficient profit.
Wednesday, 7 May 2014
Parking in Harlesden Town Centre
It is good to see that most of the work on pavements around Harlesden Library is now complete as I went past this grey morning, but I notice that there is some parking on the pavements. I have asked the officers to enforce against this as parking on the pavements will crack them up.
Tuesday, 6 May 2014
Boris Johnson Supported the Iraq War
I notice that Boris Johnson is now implying he was against the Iraq War by criticising Blair. I went on the big anti war march, but I don't recall Boris Johnson. Boris, as is his wont, has been frivolous on the subject before. He has also appeared to make remarks in favour of the Iraq invasion in the past. The BBC record him as voting against an anti invasion amendment.
I wonder what might have made him change his mind?
Total disaster maybe?
I wonder what might have made him change his mind?
Total disaster maybe?
Ash Tree Dieback in Brent
An estimate of tree deaths from Ash tree dieback is out. The figures are gloomy with 80% loss looking likely. In Brent, we have seven or eight hundred ash trees in the streets. That kind of death rate would be about 600, equivalent to Brent's total tree loss over one and a half years. That is not counting however many there are in Brent's parks.
Monday, 5 May 2014
Registering to Vote
Tomorrow is the deadline to register to vote in time for the elections on 22 May. Every election there are seats that change hands by very narrow majorities, so a handful of votes can make all the difference.
Sunday, 4 May 2014
Bristol Water Slide
I can't help but remark how the Bristol Water Slide seems to add to peoples lives at very little cost. Perhaps this message might be taken home for libraries, arts etc. as well?
Harlesden Jubilee Clock Movement
As I mentioned some time ago, this week should see the temporary removal of the Harlesden Jubilee Clock. This is part of the final phase of the Harlesden Town Centre rebuild. The clock will be refurbished and restored to its original position.
UPDATE
The date has now been moved back to late June.
UPDATE
The date has now been moved back to late June.
Saturday, 3 May 2014
How Far Can Public Health Spending Go?
Calderdale is reportedly putting aside some of its Public Health Budget for road safety. Intellectually, thais makes a lot of sense. 20mph zones have a well documented and beneficial effect on public health. Spending their public health funds in that way may well save more lives than whatever else they were planning to do with it, but I suspect it will still be seen as too radical a step for many people, who would prefer the money to be spent more traditionally _ on anti-smoking campaigns for example.
However, my view is that local authorities taking on the public health responsibilities gives an opportunity for a much more imaginative use of such funds for issues that traditionally don't get the attention they deserve; for example, air quality.
However, my view is that local authorities taking on the public health responsibilities gives an opportunity for a much more imaginative use of such funds for issues that traditionally don't get the attention they deserve; for example, air quality.
Friday, 2 May 2014
Lack of Debate
The stereotype of election campaigns are that they are supposed to be opportunities for debate, with the various candidates putting forward proposals. Sadly I don't think this is really true either in Westminster or locally in Brent. The specious promises of the Liberal Democrats are one such indication.
As is well known, Brent is facing swingeing cuts from central government on top of those we have already endured, but I see little sign of any debate as to what the options are for dealing with them. The more obvious changes have already been implemented. Over the last four years, the main mechanism in Brent has been the One Council programme. This has delivered more than £70 million in savings, and in some cases led to considerable service improvements. However, few future projects have been identified for the One Council work programme.
I also detect a general unwillingness to face up to the tens of millions that need to be found, or the difficult decisions that will be inevitable in finding solutions. The longer such questions are put off the more difficult will be the final reckoning.
As is well known, Brent is facing swingeing cuts from central government on top of those we have already endured, but I see little sign of any debate as to what the options are for dealing with them. The more obvious changes have already been implemented. Over the last four years, the main mechanism in Brent has been the One Council programme. This has delivered more than £70 million in savings, and in some cases led to considerable service improvements. However, few future projects have been identified for the One Council work programme.
I also detect a general unwillingness to face up to the tens of millions that need to be found, or the difficult decisions that will be inevitable in finding solutions. The longer such questions are put off the more difficult will be the final reckoning.
Thursday, 1 May 2014
Willesden Library Centre Finally Visible
I am glad to see that the new Library Centre for Willesden is finally taking shape. Hopefully this will put to rest the rather strange idea that was being circulated that was not going to be a Library Centre. I find it hard to understand why people invent such stories, but people can now see for themselves that they are untrue.
Wednesday, 30 April 2014
Possible Legal Challenge on Housing
Red Brick Blog has some fairly dire warnings about social housing waiting lists in London. Amazingly, I see that Brent is not as harsh as I assumed. The ten year test of residency in Barking and Dagenham seems likely to open that Borough to a highly credible challenge on indirect discrimation grounds.
Local Accountability in Schools
The Labour Party wants to restore local accountability to schools, including the ability to open community schools. This is all to the good. Whereas growing independence for schools may have been the right move in the days of LMS, it has now reached a point of disintegration, with the only oversight provided by civil servants in Whitehall. Whitehall simply hasn't the ability to monitor individual schools all over the country. Some sort of "middle tier" is inevitable unless school standards are going to be subject no accountability whatever. It is a shame that policy makers in Whitehall have taken so long to realise this.
Tuesday, 29 April 2014
Wembley Library Story Telling
A photo I took yesterday at one of the CityReadLondon story telling events (This one in Wembley Library). Events like these, or indeed all the events commemorating the British Empire Exhibition, would have been far less frequent without the Libraries Transformation Project.
Extreme Conservatism of the Loony Left
I often wonder why it is that those who consider themselves to be left wing are in reality frequently bitterly resistant to change. This is something of a paradox, as in principle such people are dedicated to the utter transformation of society, but in practice they are doggedly resistant to even slight changes in the ways things are done. I wonder why that should be?
Monday, 28 April 2014
Paradoxes of Debate
My post yesterday referred to a comment on a libraries post. I have now deleted the comment because (presumably because the author was so enraged) it did not make sense.
However, it did refer to a belief that is widespread among Library campaigners in Brent, but which does not, in my view, accord with the facts. They repeatedly state that no one agrees with the policy.
The commentator in question stated that no one in the Labour Group agreed with the policy. The sheer implausibility of this always strikes me. The libraries policy voted through in April 2011 remains in place, and no paper has ever been presented to change it. If most people disagree with the policy why would that be?
Taking it another way, it is alleged that I alone forced through a policy against the wishes of the other 40 members of the Labour Group. How did I manage to outvote the other forty? It would be a useful trick if one knew how to do it. In fact, I have never once been challenged by any member of the Executive on the Libraries policy. The Labour Group has discussed it more often than any other policy, and it is fair to say that individuals have from time to time expressed disquiet on particular aspects, but no one ever seriously challenged. In terms of votes at Full Council or various Executive meetings, the matter has been put to the vote time and time again. No member of the Labour Group has ever voted against it.
Why therefore, do some people seem to think there is widespread opposition to the Libraries policy in the Labour Group?
I think the answer is twofold. Firstly, as I explained yesterday, some campaigners are so passionately attached to their view that they simply cannot acknowledge contrary facts. Hence the continuing conviction that Brent libraries have somehow failed when in fact Brent bucks the national trend. Secondly, I am sorry to say that some people in the Labour Party agree to things in party meetings, but then go out and say something quite different elsewhere. What continues to surprise me is that some of the people they speak to continue to accept such people's statements at face value when they are obviously false.
However, it did refer to a belief that is widespread among Library campaigners in Brent, but which does not, in my view, accord with the facts. They repeatedly state that no one agrees with the policy.
The commentator in question stated that no one in the Labour Group agreed with the policy. The sheer implausibility of this always strikes me. The libraries policy voted through in April 2011 remains in place, and no paper has ever been presented to change it. If most people disagree with the policy why would that be?
Taking it another way, it is alleged that I alone forced through a policy against the wishes of the other 40 members of the Labour Group. How did I manage to outvote the other forty? It would be a useful trick if one knew how to do it. In fact, I have never once been challenged by any member of the Executive on the Libraries policy. The Labour Group has discussed it more often than any other policy, and it is fair to say that individuals have from time to time expressed disquiet on particular aspects, but no one ever seriously challenged. In terms of votes at Full Council or various Executive meetings, the matter has been put to the vote time and time again. No member of the Labour Group has ever voted against it.
Why therefore, do some people seem to think there is widespread opposition to the Libraries policy in the Labour Group?
I think the answer is twofold. Firstly, as I explained yesterday, some campaigners are so passionately attached to their view that they simply cannot acknowledge contrary facts. Hence the continuing conviction that Brent libraries have somehow failed when in fact Brent bucks the national trend. Secondly, I am sorry to say that some people in the Labour Party agree to things in party meetings, but then go out and say something quite different elsewhere. What continues to surprise me is that some of the people they speak to continue to accept such people's statements at face value when they are obviously false.
Sunday, 27 April 2014
New Powers to Limit Betting Shops
It looks like Councils will finally get powers to stop clusters of betting shops. This is an issue that has been bubbling along for some time. I am glad that changes are finally in sight, although it seems to involve a bit of a change of heart by the Tories and Liberal Democrats.
UPDATE
It looks like the betting industry will fight these measures as hard as they can, which given the amount of money they make, is not surprising.
UPDATE
It looks like the betting industry will fight these measures as hard as they can, which given the amount of money they make, is not surprising.
Comments and Democratic Debate
I had a comment to this post that illustrates some of the peculiarities of comments on blogs. The (as usual) anonymous has a typically aggressive and uncompromising tone.
Firstly, it complains that I am blogging at all. Well no one forces you to read what I write. If you don't want to that is fine. I was interested in local government and politics long before I became a councillor, so it would be odd if that interest were suddenly cease once I cease to be a councillor.
I think what the commentator really finds difficult is knowing some one else disagrees with him. This is not confined to the Library debate. A still more striking example can be found in the comment trail to my post on the Willesden Town Green proposal. Some of the comments seem to regard any disagreement with their own views as an "insult". If you are really never able to disagree with someone because of a supposed insult, it is hard to see how anyone can debate the merits of an issue.
A related problem is a tendency to ignore inconvenient facts. I get the impression that the commentator on my library post simply can't bring himself to accept that Brent library usage has gone up because it contradicts his deeply felt prejudices. I am reminded of a twitter exchange I had with Liberal Democrat councillor Alison Hopkins a while ago, where she ended up denouncing "cold statistics" in a way that seemed to me tantamount to saying "If my opinions are contradicted by the facts; I ignore the facts."
Ignoring the facts and trying to shout down people who say things you don't like does not seem to be a good way to design policy.
Firstly, it complains that I am blogging at all. Well no one forces you to read what I write. If you don't want to that is fine. I was interested in local government and politics long before I became a councillor, so it would be odd if that interest were suddenly cease once I cease to be a councillor.
I think what the commentator really finds difficult is knowing some one else disagrees with him. This is not confined to the Library debate. A still more striking example can be found in the comment trail to my post on the Willesden Town Green proposal. Some of the comments seem to regard any disagreement with their own views as an "insult". If you are really never able to disagree with someone because of a supposed insult, it is hard to see how anyone can debate the merits of an issue.
A related problem is a tendency to ignore inconvenient facts. I get the impression that the commentator on my library post simply can't bring himself to accept that Brent library usage has gone up because it contradicts his deeply felt prejudices. I am reminded of a twitter exchange I had with Liberal Democrat councillor Alison Hopkins a while ago, where she ended up denouncing "cold statistics" in a way that seemed to me tantamount to saying "If my opinions are contradicted by the facts; I ignore the facts."
Ignoring the facts and trying to shout down people who say things you don't like does not seem to be a good way to design policy.
Saturday, 26 April 2014
The Future which Doesn't Work
There are often complaints about the restrictions on car use that Brent's planning and transport policies impose. A recent TfL study again underlines why these are necessary. Unrestricted car use will endlessly increase until there is permanent gridlock.
The measures to encourage other kinds of transport, rather than being anti-car as commonly perceived, are the only way to keep traffic moving in urban areas. There is nothing "pro car" about sitting in a succession of traffic jams.
The measures to encourage other kinds of transport, rather than being anti-car as commonly perceived, are the only way to keep traffic moving in urban areas. There is nothing "pro car" about sitting in a succession of traffic jams.
Friday, 25 April 2014
Change in Brent Libraries
One of the frustrating things about explaining Brent Libraries Strategy is that many people think that the library service basically stays the same. It is a bit like education in that people hark back to the way libraries were when they were children, and treat that as an ideal from which they must never deviate.
In fact, even in the three years since, we embarked on the Libraries Transformation Project, Brent libraries have changed out of recognition. I have already blogged on the overall rise in numbers, the growth of the home library service and the outreach service. One could also mention changing IT use in either its technological or social aspects.
One way of seeing how dramatic the changes can be is to look at the changes in visits to each library. Here are the 2011/2012 figures:
You can see that Willesden is by far the biggest, with almost three times as many visits as "Wembley" (which is of course the old Brent Town Hall Library, not the new Wembley Library in Brent Civic Centre). Many people are also surprised that the six libraries that we closed only accounted for 12.6% of the total visits.
The next year, overall visits went up slightly, and the split looked like this:
In fact, even in the three years since, we embarked on the Libraries Transformation Project, Brent libraries have changed out of recognition. I have already blogged on the overall rise in numbers, the growth of the home library service and the outreach service. One could also mention changing IT use in either its technological or social aspects.
One way of seeing how dramatic the changes can be is to look at the changes in visits to each library. Here are the 2011/2012 figures:
You can see that Willesden is by far the biggest, with almost three times as many visits as "Wembley" (which is of course the old Brent Town Hall Library, not the new Wembley Library in Brent Civic Centre). Many people are also surprised that the six libraries that we closed only accounted for 12.6% of the total visits.
The next year, overall visits went up slightly, and the split looked like this:
Kilburn Library is noticeably bigger following its refurbishment, and all six libraries have grown somewhat. Again, Willesden is by far the biggest. The following year, the picture changes dramatically:
Willesden has shrunk dramatically as the rebuild started. Even so, even the interim service manages to be Brent's second biggest library. However, the new Wembley Library has seen usage explode.
This gives some idea of how artificial it is to pick one particular year. The situation is changing so rapidly that the 2012/2013 data is dramatically out of date. During 2014/2015, I expect the numbers to go up again as the full year effect of the new Wembley Library feeds in. The year after that, 2015/2016, should see yet more growth as the new Willesden Library Centre will then be open.
I find all this much more inspiring than the gentle decline that we had before.
UPDATE
The absolute figures are here.
ANOTHER UPDATE
A comment asks for library by library issues for each library for 2013/14. Visits by each library are the percentages for that year given above. The total figure as given here is 1,654,807. There is obviously a similar break down for 2013/14 for issues, with the total figure being 996,890, but the whole argument I am making is that selecting one particular year is artificial. Wembley is virtually certain to go up this year. Willesden will go up once it reopens in 2015. Year by year figures tell you little. It is also the case that many Brent library loans occur outside the buildings altogether.
UPDATE
The absolute figures are here.
ANOTHER UPDATE
A comment asks for library by library issues for each library for 2013/14. Visits by each library are the percentages for that year given above. The total figure as given here is 1,654,807. There is obviously a similar break down for 2013/14 for issues, with the total figure being 996,890, but the whole argument I am making is that selecting one particular year is artificial. Wembley is virtually certain to go up this year. Willesden will go up once it reopens in 2015. Year by year figures tell you little. It is also the case that many Brent library loans occur outside the buildings altogether.
Thursday, 24 April 2014
Dumping in Harlesden Town Centre
Going through Harlesden Town Centre the other day, I was struck at how untidy it still looks. There is evidently still a lot of trade waste dumping despite the reorganisation of the trade waste enforcement team in April last year. Now that we have the new Public Realm Contract, we should be able to introduce time banded collections, although I suspect that this will not be until the road works are finished. Even then it will not happen overnight, but need persistence and, of course, the support of the traders themselves.
Wednesday, 23 April 2014
Furness Primary School Playground
I just thought I would do a quick post on how welcome the changes to Furness School playground are. It is so much better than the old dull tarmac.
Tuesday, 22 April 2014
Housing and Planning Applications
I have picked up a sense of confusion in some recent planning discussions around what a planning authority can demand in terms of housing in a planning application.
Affordable?
The first confusion is around market, affordable and social housing. Market housing is easiest. That is just housijng sold at the market price. Generally, that is where a developer makes the main profit that funds the project. The real confusion comes with affordable housing. This means housing rented at 80% of market rate. In London that can easily be seriously unaffordable for many people. Social housing is more genuinely affordable, but seems to be being steadily eroded not just in planning conditions but also through the Right to Buy.
Tenure Mix
Two more things to look out for are whether the properties are sold or rented. If sold, they can sometimes by subject to shared ownership or other concessionary schemes. It is also worth looking at the mix of sizes. A viable community should have some family and some smaller accommodation. However, the market currently favours one or two bedroom flats over family accommodation. Brent therefore tries to push developers to include more family accommodation.
Negotiation
The third area where people seem to misunderstand is the nature of a planning authority's powers. Brent cannot simply demand whatever it wants. it has to be able to demonstrate that its decisions are in line with various planning policy documents (or deviate from them for a good reason), and that its demands are reasonable and proportionate. Developers generally try to reduce the proportion of non-market housing by pleading poverty. In recent times, the Council has started putting in a clawback position in cases where the developer subsequently stands to make a killing.
Frequently, the Council is seeking to trade off one benefit against another. Thus the Willesden Library development was judged justified in not having non market housing because the developer was paying for a new cultural centre, for example.
Affordable?
The first confusion is around market, affordable and social housing. Market housing is easiest. That is just housijng sold at the market price. Generally, that is where a developer makes the main profit that funds the project. The real confusion comes with affordable housing. This means housing rented at 80% of market rate. In London that can easily be seriously unaffordable for many people. Social housing is more genuinely affordable, but seems to be being steadily eroded not just in planning conditions but also through the Right to Buy.
Tenure Mix
Two more things to look out for are whether the properties are sold or rented. If sold, they can sometimes by subject to shared ownership or other concessionary schemes. It is also worth looking at the mix of sizes. A viable community should have some family and some smaller accommodation. However, the market currently favours one or two bedroom flats over family accommodation. Brent therefore tries to push developers to include more family accommodation.
Negotiation
The third area where people seem to misunderstand is the nature of a planning authority's powers. Brent cannot simply demand whatever it wants. it has to be able to demonstrate that its decisions are in line with various planning policy documents (or deviate from them for a good reason), and that its demands are reasonable and proportionate. Developers generally try to reduce the proportion of non-market housing by pleading poverty. In recent times, the Council has started putting in a clawback position in cases where the developer subsequently stands to make a killing.
Frequently, the Council is seeking to trade off one benefit against another. Thus the Willesden Library development was judged justified in not having non market housing because the developer was paying for a new cultural centre, for example.
Monday, 21 April 2014
Local Welfare Assistance
The Guardian has a good piece on the facts around local welfare assistance. What is does not bring out is the extent to which Councils are constrained by central government policy. Not only did central government simply shunt the responsibility on to Councils with a significant reduction in funding, it did so with very little notice. It is also inherently harder for local authorities to give out loans since (unlike the DWP) they cannot dock benefits. That means that they cannot recover past assistance and roll it over into next year in the way the DWP could. Hence there is even less funding in the system, even ignoring the 10% cut.
There is also every prospect of the entire funding being cut from 2015, which would leave Councils cutting services even further to carry on the payments, or simply stop the scheme altogether. In turn this makes Councils reluctant to publicise the system since it may not exist soon.
The whole policy is one designed to fail, but with the blame transferred away from central government. As such it is one of Iain Duncan Smith's most cynical manoeuvres.
There is also every prospect of the entire funding being cut from 2015, which would leave Councils cutting services even further to carry on the payments, or simply stop the scheme altogether. In turn this makes Councils reluctant to publicise the system since it may not exist soon.
The whole policy is one designed to fail, but with the blame transferred away from central government. As such it is one of Iain Duncan Smith's most cynical manoeuvres.
Sunday, 20 April 2014
David Cameron Looking Both Ways
I see that David Cameron is now being called on to make good on his claims about the UK being a "Christian country". His presumably Lynton Crosby inspired dog whistle to Christian groups appears to be running up against his previous attempts to appeal to gays. I wonder which will win out?


