Search This Blog

Wednesday, 14 May 2014

Debating the Issues

I had another comment on the libraries issue on this blog, which I am not going to publish as it is abusive about a named councillor.  Descending to personal abuse in anonymous posts is not an attractive characteristic. 

However, the phenomenon of ad hominum attacks is worth commenting on.  I have mentioned before that both councillors and officers get targeted personally by these commentators.  One way of seeing this is as a campaign target for people with a weak case.  If the facts support your opponent, an obvious way to overcome that is to smear the person rather than the policy.

I think, however, that is just too rational.

The people concerned just seem too enraged.  Taking the libraries issue.  One might imagine that anyone who thinks libraries are a good thing would welcome the increase in numbers at Brent libraries, not to mention the greater satisfaction levels of Brent library users.  If you are a Brent resident, you might take some satisfaction in Brent libraries outperforming those elsewhere

In fact all these facts just seem to make some people angry, and I can only assume that these sort of debates have become personal contests for them devoid of actual effects.  The actual effect on peoples' lives is simply a non-issue for them, because they are just interested in proving themselves right in some sort of self absorbed debating game. 

No comments:

Post a Comment